Judge rules HUD's $1.3 billion homelessness set-aside unlawful and reopens part of the grant competition
U.S. District Judge Mary S. McElroy ruled Nov. 20 that HUD exceeded its authority by reserving Continuum of Care money for new transitional housing and services projects. Communities may resubmit second-tier applications until Dec. 1, and HUD must award that money by Dec. 31.
Providence. A federal judge in Rhode Island ruled Nov. 20 that the Department of Housing and Urban Development exceeded its authority when it reserved $1.3 billion of this year's Continuum of Care homelessness funding for new transitional housing and supportive services projects, and ordered HUD to let communities resubmit their applications for that money by Dec. 1.
U.S. District Judge Mary S. McElroy ruled in two suits, one brought by the National Alliance to End Homelessness, the National Low Income Housing Coalition, other nonprofits and local governments, the other by 20 states and the District of Columbia. In August she threw out HUD's whole funding notice for lack of public comment; the challengers dropped that claim in September to have the ruling vacated on appeal. This time she decided their other claims and struck specific provisions instead.
What the court struck
The homelessness law tells HUD to weigh applicants' past performance and success in moving people into permanent housing. The set-aside, the judge wrote, kept existing and permanent housing projects from most second-tier money "regardless of the merits." HUD must now fund second-tier projects, new and renewal alike, in order of score. The appeals court's September stay, she wrote, addressed only public comment, not HUD's authority.
She also vacated points for requiring residents to take part in services, finding that HUD ignored domestic violence providers, whom federal law bars from mandating services. In the nonprofits' case alone she struck points for avoiding harm reduction work; a criterion rewarding continuums that do not "interfere with or impede" encampment clearing, which she held violates the First Amendment; HUD's definition of self-sufficiency; and conditions to follow a list of executive orders that HUD never explained. She upheld points for sober housing and for partnering with treatment providers.
New deadlines
First-tier awards, which must cover at least 60 percent of each continuum's annual renewal need, are not delayed: HUD must make them by Dec. 1 without the vacated provisions. Continuums may resubmit second-tier applications until 11:59 p.m. Eastern time on Dec. 1, and HUD must award that money by Dec. 31. HUD had argued that rerunning the competition could leave gaps when existing grants begin to expire Jan. 1.
“A delay of up to 30 days in obligating Tier 2 funds should have minimal impact, because Tier 2 awards will be complete before existing grants begin to expire on January 1, 2027.”
HUD must file a compliance plan by Nov. 25, and either side may object to the deadlines by Nov. 24. A day before the ruling, the nonprofits told the court HUD had informed applicants it expected to announce awards Dec. 11. HUD's competition page did not mention the ruling on Nov. 21.
About this story
501c3.help wrote this story from the sources listed with it, not from material an organization sent. Our editors approved it on Nov. 21, 2026. Stories in The Nonprofit Herald are free, and nothing is asked in return. Editorial rules.
Found an error? Write to [email protected] and we will correct it.