Half of nonprofit hospitals get more in tax breaks than they spend on their communities, Lown Institute says; hospital group disputes the method
The Boston think tank's report, released Nov. 17, puts the gap at $15.5 billion for fiscal 2023. The American Hospital Association answered on Nov. 20 that the measure leaves out billions in benefits.
The five largest fair share deficits in the Lown Institute report, fiscal 2023
Boston. Fifty-two percent of the country's nonprofit hospitals received more in tax breaks in fiscal 2023 than they spent on charity care and community investment, according to a report the Lown Institute, a think tank based in Needham, Mass., released on Nov. 17. Together, the institute said, those hospitals ran what it calls a fair share deficit of $15.5 billion.
The institute examined more than 3,000 hospitals in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, using IRS Form 990 filings, federal hospital cost reports and municipal property data. It estimated that nonprofit hospitals received $38.8 billion in tax exemptions in 2023, an average of $13 million per hospital, including exemptions on $240 billion worth of real estate. The hospitals in deficit received $27.5 billion in exemptions and gave back $12 billion, by its count.
What the institute counts
The report counts five categories from the Form 990: financial assistance, community health improvement services, subsidized health services, cash and in-kind contributions, and community building activities. It leaves out medical research, the training of health professionals and the losses hospitals report when Medicaid pays less than the cost of care.
The largest deficits it found were at Mayo Clinic Hospital in Rochester, Minn., Tisch Hospital and New York-Presbyterian Hospital in New York, Stanford Hospital in California and Massachusetts General Hospital in Boston. Hospitals in California, Florida, Illinois and Ohio each had a combined deficit of more than $1 billion. The institute asks policymakers to strengthen charity care standards, tighten community benefit reporting and set minimum spending targets for community investment.
“Tax exemptions aren't a gift, they're an expectation, and regulators need to make sure all hospitals hold up their end of the bargain.”
The hospitals' answer
The American Hospital Association replied in a blog post on Nov. 20 that the report uses an artificially narrow measure of community benefit. It cited an analysis by EY, prepared for the association from IRS data, that found nonprofit hospitals provided about $149 billion in community benefits in 2022, against $13.2 billion in federal tax exemptions and an estimated $41.1 billion in state and local exemptions.
Federal rules require nonprofit hospitals to provide community benefits but do not require that the spending equal the value of their tax exemptions, The Worcester Guardian noted in its report on the Massachusetts figures.
About this story
501c3.help wrote this story from the sources listed with it, not from material an organization sent. Our editors approved it on Nov. 21, 2026. Stories in The Nonprofit Herald are free, and nothing is asked in return. Editorial rules.
Found an error? Write to [email protected] and we will correct it.
For Lown Institute: put the badge on your website
Put it on your About page or wherever you list press mentions, rather than in a footer that repeats on every page. It links to this story.
Linking is welcome and never required. Nothing about the story changes either way.